Skip to content

Cart

Your cart is empty

Article: Buying Stone Objects: What to Check First

Orange onyx block bowl catching low sun on an oak dresser beside a brass clock, at the foot of a linen-made bed
Buying Guide

Buying Stone Objects: What to Check First

Four things decide a stone object before it is bought: whether it is stone, whether it is sound, how it is finished, and what it will be asked to do. The veining is not one of them.

Start at an edge. In marble, onyx or travertine the pattern runs over the edge and on across the side and the underside, because it runs through the block; a print or a cast stops at a skin, or repeats. Then run a fingernail across any line that is not plainly a vein, look at how even the finish is, and match the finish to the place the object will live.

Variation is not on the list. Two pieces of the same design will never carry the same pattern, and that is how stone forms rather than a fault to inspect for. What separates a well-made stone object from a poor one is in the cut, the finish and the base, and all three can be checked in a minute.

Orange onyx bowl with amber veining beside two stacked books and a stone lamp, on a travertine side table by a sofa

Is It Stone?

How can you tell real marble from an imitation?
Follow the veining over an edge. In stone it continues through the side and onto the underside without a break. On a printed or coated surface it stops at a seam, and on a cast it often repeats.

Read the name first. A listing that says marble, onyx or travertine is naming a stone. "Marble-look", "marble effect", "faux marble" and "cultured marble" are naming something else: a print, a coating, or a cast of resin and stone dust. None of them is wrong in itself, but none of them wears, weighs or ages like stone.

A cast gives itself away at the joins. Resin is poured into a mold that comes apart in two halves, and the line where they met is usually sanded but rarely gone; look along the sides of a bowl or the underside of a tray for a faint ridge. Resin also traps tiny air bubbles that show as pinholes under a polished face. Stone has neither. Where a stone object carries a hole, it belongs to the stone, and travertine is the one that carries many.

Weight is the plainest check of all. Stone is heavy for its size, and a stone object should feel heavier than it looks when it is first lifted; a resin copy of the same form is noticeably lighter. A stone picture frame is a useful reference point, set out in choosing a picture frame material. Onyx adds one more test: held to a window, a thin edge glows, which marble does far less and an opaque resin does not do at all. Marble versus onyx covers how the two stones differ in use.

Is It Sound?

How do you check a stone object for cracks?
Run a fingernail across any line that is not clearly a vein. A vein is solid stone, and the nail passes over it. A line that catches the nail has opened. Look at it again with a light held low across the surface, and check whether it shows on the other face.

Stone carries two kinds of line, and only one is a concern. A fissure is a natural separation that formed with the stone; most are closed, the nail slides over them, and they have been there for as long as the block has. A crack is damage that happened later, from a knock in transit or a cut taken too hard. Both look like a fine line at first glance, which is why the fingernail is the test rather than the eye.

Light helps. An overhead lamp hides a line that runs in the same direction as the light, so hold a phone flashlight low and close to the surface and sweep it slowly across; an open line throws a thin shadow. Then turn the piece over. A line that shows on one face only is usually at the surface. A line that shows on both faces runs through the piece, and on a tray or a board, a gentle press on either side of it will tell you whether anything gives.

Where the line sits matters as much as what it is. Along a long, solid edge it is rarely a risk. Across a narrow neck, a stem, a handle or the thin wall of a bowl, it is the place the piece will part if it is ever dropped, and that is the one to leave on the shelf.

Orange onyx block bowl in warm light beside a glass carafe and books, on an oak nightstand by a linen bed

Holes, Fills and Travertine

Should travertine be filled or left open?
Either is sound; they behave differently. Filled travertine has its holes closed with a resin or cement fill, so the face is smooth. Unfilled travertine keeps them open, so the surface is textured and catches light, water and dust in the voids.

Travertine is laid down by mineral-rich water rather than compressed, and it forms with voids running through it, which is why its surface is open; the nature of travertine sets out how it forms. A fill is not a repair and not a defect. It is a choice about the surface.

Choose by use. On a surface that is wiped often, a filled face is easier to keep clean. On an object that is mostly looked at, open voids give travertine the texture it is chosen for. In a bathroom, open voids hold a little soap and water, which is care rather than damage: rinse, and let the piece dry. What is worth checking is the fill itself, where there is one. It should sit flush with the face and be close in tone to the stone around it, not raised, shrunken or lifting at its edge.

How It Is Finished

What should you check on the finish of a stone object?
That it is even. A polish should carry across the whole face, over the rim and into any hollow without dull patches; a hone should be one consistent matte. Edges should run true, and the base should be smooth or padded so it does not mark a table.

Honed and polished are both finishes, not grades, and the choice between them is about use rather than quality. A polished face reflects light and shows an etch as a dull spot against the shine; a honed face is already matte, so the same etch blends in. Honed versus polished surfaces covers the choice in full. What matters at the point of buying is that the finish chosen has been carried all the way through.

The quickest check is inside a bowl. A hollow is the hardest place to finish, and a bowl polished on its outer faces and left dull inside has been finished where it is easy rather than where it is used. Then turn the piece over. A rough-cut underside will scratch a lacquered or oiled table the first time it is moved; a well-made piece has a base that is ground smooth or carries a protective pad.

Where stone meets metal, look at the joint. A brass stem or handle should seat into the stone without a gap, a wobble or a visible bead of adhesive. If anything turns that should not, the joint will only loosen with use.

Orange onyx bowl beside an hourglass and a black vase of dried pods, on an oak sideboard in a study with shelves

What It Will Be Asked to Do

Does the use change what to check?
Yes. Anything that touches food or sits in a bathroom will meet acid, oil or water every day. Marble and onyx are calcium carbonate, so acid etches them. Choose the finish for that use, and plan to wipe spills rather than leave them.

For the table, the question is acid. Lemon, wine, tomato and vinegar dull marble and onyx where they sit, and the risk is the spill left overnight rather than the slice served on a board. Whether marble is safe for serving food sets out what that means in practice.

For the bath, the question is standing water. A dispenser or a tumbler lives wet, and the base is the part that sits in a ring of water on the counter. A honed face shows water marks less than a polished one. For decorative objects that will only be looked at, none of this applies, and the finish can be chosen for light alone.

None of this is a reason to avoid stone. It is a reason to know which materials improve with use and which are kept, a distinction drawn in choosing objects that age well over time.

What Not to Check For

Should two stone pieces from the same design match?
No. Each is cut from a different section of stone, so the veining, banding and tone will differ every time. Expect the same palette and the same character of movement, not the same pattern.

A buyer who inspects for matching veining is inspecting for something stone cannot do. The pattern was set when the stone formed, and the cut only decides which part of it shows; why no two stone pieces are alike explains where it comes from, and what to expect from natural materials sets the baseline. Spend the minute on the edges, the lines and the finish instead.

Orange onyx bowl in a patch of sun beside a bonsai and a hammered tray, on an oak coffee table by a boucle sofa

Choosing a Piece

The Marigold bowl shows the edge test at its clearest. It is orange onyx, carved into a low block bowl and polished on every face, so the amber and white veining runs without a break from the flat sides over a sharp rim and down into the hollow. The polish carries into the interior too, which is the place a bowl is hardest to finish. It measures 7.5 inches square and weighs about seven pounds.

For travertine, the Tallinn bath set is gray-brown stone chiseled in a diagonal relief across four pieces, with only the canister lid left smooth. The stone's open grain shows inside the chiseling, so the pits read as part of the material rather than as a finish laid on it.

The Concorde stand pairs black marble with brass: two round tiers with a softly lobed edge on a single satin brass stem, the gray veining sweeping across both surfaces and through the edge profile. It is 13 inches tall and about twelve pounds. The Hanover arch is white marble carved from one block, honed flutes on the outside and a smooth inner face, 8 inches tall and around five pounds.

Quick Answers

How can you tell if marble is real?
Follow the veining over an edge. In real marble it continues through the side and onto the underside, because it runs through the block. A printed or coated surface stops at a seam, and a resin cast often repeats its pattern and shows a mold line. Real stone also feels heavier than it looks.

How do you check stone decor for cracks?
Run a fingernail across any line that is not clearly a vein. A vein is solid and the nail passes over it; a line that catches has opened. Sweep a light low across the surface, then check the other face. A line through a narrow neck, stem or thin wall is the one to avoid.

Is filled or unfilled travertine better for home objects?
Neither is better; they suit different uses. Filled travertine has its holes closed with resin or cement, so the face is smooth and easy to wipe. Unfilled keeps its voids open, which gives the texture travertine is chosen for. Where there is a fill, it should sit flush and match the stone's tone.

What should you check on the finish of a stone object?
Check that the finish is even. A polish should carry over the rim and into any hollow without dull patches, and a hone should be one consistent matte. Edges should run true, any metal should seat without a gap, and the base should be smooth or padded so it does not scratch a table.

What should you check before buying stone for the kitchen or bath?
Check the finish against the use. Marble and onyx are calcium carbonate, so acid from lemon, wine or tomato etches them, and an etch shows more on a polished face than a honed one. In a bathroom, look at the base, which sits in water. Plan to wipe spills rather than leave them.

Final Note

Buying stone well takes a minute and four questions. Is it stone, which the edge and the weight will tell you. Is it sound, which a fingernail will tell you. Is it finished all the way through, which the inside of a bowl and the underside will tell you. And is the finish right for where it will live.

Everything else is the stone being stone. The pattern will not match the photograph, and the next piece will not match this one. That is the part to choose for, not to check against.

Read more

Black and white resin napkin rings holding pink linen napkins, a round travertine dining table set for six
Buying Guide

How to Choose Napkin Rings: Fit, Band Width and Material

A napkin ring is chosen by the napkin it has to hold: the fit decides whether the cloth stays put, the band decides how much of it shows, and the material decides how the ring is kept.

Read more
Steel and wood cocktail shaker with a double jigger, coupes and a glass of ice on a dark wood bar counter at dusk
Bar Tools

How to Choose a Cocktail Set: Shaker, Size and What Completes It

A cocktail set is chosen around its shaker, which decides what else the set needs, how many drinks it makes at once and how it feels in use.

Read more